The Fes Tannery, Cross-Examined
Above the dye vats of the Chouara Tannery in Fes, the old craft holds up to scrutiny and the leather-shop pitch built around it mostly doesn't.
Fes: The Tannery Terrace

A lane in Fes el-Bali, closed to cars like the rest of the old medina, running up to an arched gateway.
Resolved: the Fes tannery smell is worse in photos. That motion loses within seconds of climbing onto a leather shop's terrace above the Chouara Tannery, the largest of the three tanneries in Fes. It sits in Fes el-Bali, the walled old medina of the city. Below the railing, men work among a honeycomb of round stone vats, and the smell coming off them is exactly as bad as everyone says.
The white vats come first. Hides soak in them for two to three days in a mix of cow urine, pigeon droppings, quicklime, salt and water, which cleans and softens the skins so that they will take the dye, and the ammonia in the droppings does much of the softening. Only after that do the hides move to the coloured vats, where poppy gives the red, indigo the blue and henna the orange. Most accounts date the tannery to the eleventh century.
Whoever leads you up explains the pigeon droppings with a pause before the punchline and a glance to check it landed, and the same routine is running on the next terrace over. The chemistry is accurate. It is also a warm-up, because every terrace here belongs to a leather shop and the stairs back down run through its showroom.
Award the mint a point. Someone hands a sprig to every visitor at the door, and crushed under the nose it takes the edge off the smell without erasing it, which is enough to stay at the railing and watch the hides being worked. It comes with the visit the way a hard hat comes with a building site, so there is no need to treat it as a personal favour.
Take the mint, then judge the terrace and the shop below it separately.

Fes: The Leather Stall
Back down the stairs, the showroom under the terrace is where the visit was always going to end. Bags, jackets and pointed slippers cover the walls, and the opening price on any of them assumes you will haggle, as it does in most of the medina.
The man who walked you to the terrace may not be neutral either. Unofficial guides who offer to show visitors the tanneries for free are usually steering them to a shop that pays a commission. So when the man who brought you praises one shop's stitching, the praise is evidence of an arrangement before it is evidence of quality. On the question of which shop is best, his testimony is inadmissible. It says nothing either way about the bag itself.
Not everything for sale near the tannery is leather. The stall beside the showroom sells the brass trays and teapots used to serve mint tea, the sweet green tea brewed with fresh mint leaves that turns up all over Morocco.
Verdict: buy the bag if you like the bag, at whatever number you reach after haggling, and leave the guide's opinion out of the decision.
Fes: The Medina Gate
On the walk out of Fes el-Bali toward the gate, the lanes fill with babouches, the soft leather slippers sold all over Morocco, piled in tan, red and brown. Those are the colours of the vats, finished and stitched.
Fes el-Bali has been a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 1981 and is one of the largest car-free urban areas in the world, so whatever you buy leaves on foot, in your hands or on the back of a donkey.
Closing argument
Take the mint at the door. Everyone gets a sprig, and it does help.
Each viewing terrace belongs to the leather shop below it, so expect to leave through the showroom, and to tip if you buy nothing.
A stranger who offers to walk you to the tanneries for free is usually heading for a shop that pays him. Ask your riad for a licensed guide instead.
Haggle in the leather shops. The opening price assumes you will.

It is tempting to call the shops and the free guides parasites on the tannery, living off visitors the vats bring in. I'm less sure. Chouara is still a working tannery, and the people who climb the terraces and buy in the showrooms are part of the leather trade that keeps it working. How much of a shop's takings reaches the men in the vats, I have no idea.
The lane ends at Bab Bou Jeloud, the gate built in 1913 at the top of Tala'a Kebira, the main market street through the medina. Its tiles are blue on the outside and green on the side facing the lanes you just walked. ■




